After a brief silence, Nangong Tengfei raised his hand and said, "Sorry, the No. 1 prosecutor did not fully express the prosecution's intention. The most important thing is that Zhao Yan's boyfriend has no relationship with the actress queen. The actress queen helped Zhao Yan's boyfriend become a more famous singer because of Zhao Yan's face. In addition, the actress queen has always promoted Zhao Yan after becoming famous. Zhao Yan's behavior has broken through the basic morality."

Sima Luo immediately replied: "Prosecutor No. 2, your knife is very accurate, it is clearly a blame for your partner. In fact, it turns the undetermined things into facts and conducts in-depth analysis. May I ask the two prosecutors, how do you prove that the photos were leaked by Zhao Yan? I have questions to ask the witness."

After Sima Luo refuted, he walked to the only witness Wang Shou and asked, "Wang Shou, did you see Zhao Yan take away the video tape or film?"

Wang Shou replied: "No, I just saw Zhao Yan going to Brother Sheng's office."

Sima Luo said: "That is, you can't prove whether Zhao Yan took the video tape."

Judge No. 1 suddenly spoke: "I'm sorry to interrupt. This court does not apply to the suspicion of guilt. It is highly likely that it can be proved that Zhao Yan has the opportunity to get the video tape. There is no need to prove whether Zhao Yan really got the video tape. The court is temporarily suspended for half an hour, and the restaurant has prepared some snacks. The court will start in half an hour. In order, the court debate will begin with Shen Bing's crimes."

...

Sima Luo's face was not good-looking. He was eating afternoon tea alone in the restaurant. The afternoon tea was very rich and there were all kinds of handmade snacks, but Sima Luo had no intention of food.

Cao Yun took a few baskets of snacks, poured a cup of coffee and sat aside. He could understand Sima Luo's mood. When Judge No. 1 said that this court was not applicable to the suspicion of the court, Sima Luo was equivalent to being beaten with a blow. Not only Sima Luo, but also "iodine" Cao Yun's understanding. Suspicion of the suspicion of the two major legal systems is the basic legal principle recognized by both legal systems, and it is also the most important basis for lawyers to fight criminal lawsuits. As long as some evidence is proved that there is doubt, then this evidence is invalid evidence.

Situ Yan is not easy to see. The next trial is a fight between him and the prosecutor. At present, only Zhao Yan is suspected of the three defendants, and the other two are equivalent to trial, not trial. At this time, the lawyers are very needed because this is a moral court, not a normal court.

On the other hand, Nangong Tengfei was in a good mood, and he smiled and expressed his happiness at the taste of the food. Not only that, Nangong Tengfei also took the initiative to sit next to Yue Sanchi. Yue Sanchi seemed to not want to pay much attention to Nangong Tengfei at the beginning, but he didn't know what Nangong Tengfei said, so the two began to whisper.

If Cao Yun wants to place a bet, Cao Yun will come down to Situ Yan. Situ Yan's hands holding the teapot are very stable, and the tea poured happens to be eight points full. In other words, Situ Yan's heart is very quiet. As for Nangong Tengfei and Yue Sanchi, there is a saying that one monk carries water to drink, and two monks carry water to drink. Their position is a relatively awkward position, and they can't force it too hard, but they don't want to lose.

If you guessed correctly, Nangong Tengfei hoped that Yue Sanchi could be a bad person, so he expressed his opinions without hesitation. Yue Sanchi was still young after all, and listening to Nangong Tengfei's selfless explanation, he was quite grateful.

Cao Yun was not relaxed because the second war might break out tonight.

...

The first war finally began.

Yue Sanchi said: "I don't think Shen Bing has leaked photos, no motivation, and no need for this. Moreover, the leak of photos has a huge impact on Shen Bing himself. After the death of the queen of the film, Shen's Film Company was investigated many times, and many of its well-known artists terminated their contracts with Shen's Film Company, and Shen's Film Company also fell into a three-year low. At the same time, Shen Bing was the initiator of the kidnapping. In terms of causality, Shen Bing has an unshirkable main responsibility for the death of the queen of the film, and is the chief criminal."

Situ Yan said: "I disliked someone and beat him up, but I didn't expect that after being beaten, he would jump off the building and commit suicide in humiliation. Did I kill him? Of course not, the same situation was the case with Shen Bing. First, Shen Bing never wanted to leak the photos, and his request for Li Sheng also explained this point. Second, the same thing is different for different people, and suicide is a very bad behavior. The victim's actress queen did not choose to cooperate with the police to arrest the real murderer, but chose to escape suicide. This result is definitely not the result that Shen Bing is willing to see. Is Shen Bing wrong? Yes, of course, there is a mistake. He took this action against the actress queen whom many people beloved."

"On the other hand, what if Shen Bing kidnapped an unknown ordinary woman? The answer is very clear, and this case will not be mentioned in the Lieyan Court. The Lieyan Court must first prove its fairness first, that is, first remove the identity of the Film Queen before considering the case. Then ask, is Shen Bing really the first offender? In the previous trial, the prosecutor also agreed that the person who leaked the photos was the culprit. Shen Bing did not need to pay for the death of the Film Queen."

Situ Yan: "Simply put, Shen Bing wanted to control the situation and asked for unflushed film. But when the execution was carried out, there was a problem. Not only was the film washed into a photo, but there was also an additional video tape. According to the confession, Shen Bing looked for Li Sheng many times, and Li Sheng didn't care or care about the kidnapping. Wang Shou washed the film, and Li Sheng protected Wang Shou. The incident had already happened, so it could only be like this. The queen of the film knew that she was photographed and did not commit suicide. After the filming film was filmed, she still attended some events. It was the behavior of some fans that the queen of the film temporarily stopped filming. In other words, the kidnapping, the harm caused to the queen of the film itself was limited, and it would never reach the level of suicide."

Situ Yan said: "To sum up, Shen Bing is not only not the first criminal and culprit of the death of the Queen of the Film, but the responsibility for the death of the Queen of the Film, is very small. Here, I want to ask a question first, Lieyan Court, did you kill Shen Bing's only son Shen Shi?"

Shen Bing in the dock immediately stood up, but there was a rope on his neck, which was pulled by the guard behind him. Not only did he sit back in his position, but he couldn't make any noise, as if he was being tilted towards the death.

Judge No. 1 said: "Shen Bing, don't worry, your Shen family is not as good as the queen. Shen Shi's girlfriend is five months pregnant. You'd better be quiet and cooperate."

Situ Yan walked to Shen Bing, held the rope with his hand, and let go of the guard. Situ Yan said a few words in Shen Bing's ear. Shen Bing nodded, took a deep breath and tried to restrain his emotions.

Situ Yan said: "Please answer my question directly."

The three judges whispered to each other for a while, and Judge No. 1 said: "Yes, we have set up a charge against Shen Bing. Chen Shi and his son noticed something was wrong, especially Chen Shi was very smart. After discovering that Li Sheng's phone was suspected to have been eavesdropped, they began to use their brains. Chen Shi persuaded Shen Bing to surrender and explained everything to the police. The problem is that the time when Chen Shi asked Shen Bing to surrender, it happened that the 20-year prosecution period for the kidnapping case was passed. So Lieyan Court decided to get some interest from Shen Bing first."

Judge No. 1 said: "We deliberately left behind people, such as opening Shen Bing's safe, taking photos of the queen of the film, and not resetting the photo. And we also contacted Shen Bing anonymously, and someone was chasing the queen of the film. Our original intention was to hope that Shen Bing could surrender himself. However, based on the information we eavesdropped on, the reason why Chen Shi persuaded Shen Bing to surrender was that the kidnapping case passed the prosecution period. On the day of Chen Shi's death, it happened to be the day when the kidnapping case occurred 20 years ago, they planned to go to the police station the next day. In this case, the Lieyan Court can only make up for the gap in the law."

Judge No. 1 said: "The Flame Court admitted to killing Chen Shi. Does Lawyer No. 3 have any other problems?"

Situ Yan: "No. According to what I said just now, Chen Shi's responsibility for the death of the Queen of the Movie is very small. Since the Lie Yan Court has punished the Shen family and deprived him of a young life. I think the punishment of the Lie Yan Court on the Shen family should be stopped. The son pays off the debt for his father and has paid off the debt. Please ask the court to release Shen Bing."

The prosecutor Yue Sanchi said: "It is very popular to have student loans now. Students take their ID cards without wearing clothes to take photos. Some students can't afford to pay the money, and the photos are posted online. A few students committed suicide due to their parents' blaming them. I would like to ask lawyer No. 3, if the police arrested the first criminals of illegal loans, will the punishment for the first criminals be increased because some students committed suicide?"

Situ Yan thought for a long time and finally nodded: "Yes, the court will consider the consequences of the crime at its discretion."

Yue Sanchi said: "The person who lends money cannot think that the student will commit suicide, but because of his behavior, the student's suicide, he must accept more severe punishment. Here we should pay special attention. The queen of the film was taken helplessly under violent pressure. The student took photos voluntarily. There is a world of difference between the two. Since the suicide of the person who took photos voluntarily will increase the sentence, don't the sentencing of the person who was forced to take photos to commit suicide? Here, I also have to refute Shen Bing's crimes raised by lawyer No. 3. The kidnapping case caused the appearance of the photos, and the photos were the cause of the death of the queen of the film. I agree to identify the person who leaked the photos as the first offender, and I think Shen Bing must bear the responsibility next to the person who leaked the photos."

Yue Sanchi added: "I agree with lawyer No. 3. The father and son pay back their debts, and the debts are paid clearly. Don't make things difficult for Shen's family anymore. I just disagree with lawyer No. 3's slim statement."

Judge No. 1 said: "We use 100% simplicity as the benchmark. We ask the prosecutor and lawyer to rule on the defendant, how much responsibility Shen Bing has to bear. As for how to punish 100% of the responsibility and how to punish 1% of the responsibility, this is the judge's business. What you want to debate is the allocation of responsibility, not whether it is enough to repay the debt."

After the judge explained the rules, both of them sat down and thought quietly. Finally, Situ Yan said: "I think Shen Bing is responsible for 10% of the responsibility."

Yue Sanchi said: "According to my analysis, Zhao Yan is the one who leaks the photos and should bear 60% of the responsibility, and Shen Bing and Li Sheng each bear 20% of the responsibility."

Sima Luo’s socket: “It’s not decided that Zhao Yan is the one who leaks the photos.”

Judge No. 1 reminded: "Yes, we all agree that Shen Bing is not the one who leaked the photo."

Yue Sanchi didn't know what to say for a while, Nangong Tengfei said: "Everyone agreed that the person who leaked the photos was 60%, and the three main personnel involved in the kidnapping case were equally divided by 40%, and each person was 13% responsible."

Cao Yun said: "I don't agree with Li Sheng's 13% responsibility because Li Sheng didn't care much about this matter and gave it to Wang Shou. Since Wang Shou was in jail for ten years and the judicial punishment was punished, I think it's enough. Li Sheng has a maximum of 5% responsibility."

Judge No. 1 asked: "Does lawyer Zhao Yan agree to the 13% distribution of liability without considering 60% of the situation?"

Sima Luo said: "Don't agree. I think Zhao Yan's role in this case is less than that of Li Sheng. Zhao Yan is the lowest accomplice, with a maximum of 5%.

Nangong Tengfei said: "First of all, we will rule out 60% of the responsibility for the leaked photos. How to allocate 40% of the responsibility for the kidnapping case? First of all, the kidnapping case was planned by Shen Bing. Shen Bing invited Zhao Yan and asked Zhao Yan to have an appointment with the actress queen, and Shen Bing also asked Li Sheng to kidnap the actress queen. From this point of view, it is not an exaggeration for Shen Bing to bear 20% of the responsibility."

Judge No. 1 said: "I agree with the prosecutor's statement that no matter who leaks the photos, we must first distinguish the responsibility for the kidnapping case, so that we can determine how to deal with Shen Bing's crimes that did not leak the photos."

Nangong Tengfei said: "This case was caused by Shen Bing's pursuit of money and interests. I now give lawyer No. 3 a chance. I won't say that Shen Bing is willing to bear 20%. If I don't want to, we have to continue the debate."

Situ Yan was silent for a long time and asked: "How many people need to die for 20% of the responsibility?"

The judge said: "How to punish is the judge's business."

Shen Bing suddenly said, "I recognize this 20%. He is a smart person. If he knows that if he continues to argue, it is not impossible for him to exceed 30%.

Situ Yan sat back, and Nangong Tengfei didn't say anything anymore.

Judge No. 1 said: "The three defendants all participated in the kidnapping case. After excluding their parents, the three defendants plus immediate relatives have a total of 13 people. That is to say, the total number of 40% of the responsibility is 13, and every 3% is one life. 20% of the responsibility counts the six lives of your Shen family, Shen Shi one. Next, there are three lives of Shen Bing, Shen Bing’s wife and Shen Bing’s grandson. The Shen family has only four lives to repay the debt. Therefore, this court sentenced that all the Shen family members were executed."

Everyone was in an uproar, it was too cruel.

Judge No. 1 ignored it and continued: "But this court will not be so rigid. If Shen Bing cooperates with the court in the next trial, the court will agree to keep the Shen family alive. As for whom it is to keep, it will be up to Shen Bing to consider it yourself."

Paralysis, this knife kills people with ruthlessness. It is like being electrocuted, and accidentally being electrocuted is touched. It is completely different from knowing that there is electricity to get electrocuted. The Shen family was wiped out and Shen Bing chose to live. This not only gave Shen Bing hope, but also cruelly asked Shen Bing to make a choice, and also demonstrated the grandeur of the court.

Yes, you usually choose a grandson, which forces Shen Bing to kill himself and his wife who has been with him for decades. As for Cao Yun, if he was Shen Bing, he would rather be broken than be able to do anything. When he was in a desperate situation, he would be willing to sacrifice himself and dare to take down the emperor.

Of course, just thinking about it casually, the court did give hope, which made Shen Bing obedient like a grandson in the next trial.

You can play, you really know how to play. If you have a gun, you can play whatever you want.
Chapter completed!