"No matter what Qin Ke's real level is, this is a paper written by a high school student. First of all, it does not meet our prerequisites for acceptance and cannot be published."

"Mr. Xiang, I think the responsibility of our expert group is only to review the content quality of the paper. It should be the editor's job to judge whether the paper meets the acceptance criteria. Huang Feipeng submitted it, and Editor Xiao also signed and agreed to submit it to our expert group. That's it.

It means that the preliminary review and re-examination have been passed.”

"Xiao Xu, you just joined the expert group last year. You don't understand the situation. Our journal can't even publish papers from graduate students, but it also publishes papers from high school students? Isn't this funny? If it were really published, how many people would not even publish the papers?

If you don't read it, you come here to scold us for being sensational and trying to take advantage of Qin Ke's popularity? I, Lao Xiang, have been so famous all my life, but I don't want to be scolded on my spine! I will never sign my name anyway! If you insist on it,

If it passes the review, I will withdraw from this expert group!"

Other old experts responded one after another: "We are the same!"

According to the rules, at least three-quarters of the experts in the expert group must sign and agree before the paper can be considered approved.

Xiao Mao has been watching the whole process, sighing in his heart, and fame is sometimes a double-edged sword. If Qin Ke's reputation is not as big as it is now, the expert team may determine that after determining his true level, he will "adult beauty" because of his pity for talent.

, break such an exception, create a good story, and gain some good reputation for yourself.

However, Qin Ke is basically popular now. These old experts who regard themselves as aloof feel that publishing a paper for such a famous high school student is not only bad for their own reputation, but also suspected of gaining popularity, so naturally they refuse to do so.

Past draft.

Moreover, they had never seen Qin Ke with their own eyes, so it was not surprising that they refused to believe Qin Ke's ability. After all, Xiao Mao had personally studied it before he believed it - even if this was a man who had created a high school math olympiad.

Miracle gifted student.

The editor-in-chief of the magazine looked at each other, and the editor-in-chief said: "Since most of the professors in the expert group disagree..."

"etc!"

Xiao Mao finally couldn't help but stood up: "First of all, I brought this manuscript back from Yuanzhou. I have also seen Qin Ke himself and studied it personally. His level of calculus is beyond me.

Approved.”

He looked around the crowd and said in a deep voice: "Everyone should know that Professor Shi Cunyuan from Yuanzhou City is an old professor with an excellent reputation. He also personally vouched for it, confirming that this paper was basically written from conception to writing.

Qin Ke wrote it alone, Professor Shi and another high school girl only helped polish some words, typesetting, etc. Therefore, the first author of this paper is Qin Ke, there is no problem!"

"I stick to my point of view. The only criterion for judging whether a manuscript can be published is the quality of the manuscript and the true level of the author. In addition, all other conditions such as status, reputation, etc. are secondary."

"Of course, in order to ensure fairness to college students, we still cannot accept submissions from graduated teachers, professors and the like. If they want to publish, they should publish it on SCI. However, current high school students and even junior high school students, even if they are

For primary school students, as long as the paper meets the quality requirements of our journal and the author's professional level meets the academic standards of outstanding college students, it should be published!"

The elderly expert named Xiang stood up and objected: "This requirement for accepting manuscripts has been set by our "Xia Guo College Mathematics and Practical Analysis" since its inception. The name of our journal is "College Mathematics and Practical Analysis"

, is designed to serve college students, not high school students! Hundreds of years of rules and hundreds of years of persistence have made our journal what it is today..."

"Professor Xiang, I don't agree with your point of view." Xiao Mao refused to give in: "Coach Deng Hongguo said something that I especially feel, 'The world is progressing, the times are developing, mathematics is changing with each passing day, what we should do is to follow the

Open and inclusive attitude, seeking innovation and change, rather than being complacent! Can the cultural atmosphere when the journal was founded be the same as it is now? There were few college students at that time, and only current college students were allowed to publish papers in our journal in order to take the high-end and high-quality route. Now

They are so different from what they were a hundred years ago, so why can’t the rules from a hundred years ago be changed?”

The more Xiao Mao talked, the more excited he became:

"To put it bluntly, centuries-old rules have also led us to be blindly arrogant and stubborn! Now our "Xia Guo College Mathematics and Practical Analysis" only occupies the title of 'the top academic mathematics journal in the country' because of its long history.

How many newly founded journals are beginning to rise rapidly now? For example, "Mathematical Research and Exploration" has a history of only about twelve years, how fast is it becoming famous now? If we continue like this, we only have the arrogance of domestic first-class journals, but do not have the broadmindedness of first-class journals

In terms of magnanimity, within two years, we will be surpassed and we will fall behind others!"

Professor Zhang, a veteran of three dynasties, was unhappy:

"Oh, Editor Xiao, you young people are always shouting alarmistly about reform and reform. Have you ever considered the century-old reputation of our journal? Qin Ke is at the height of his fame now. If we make an exception and publish his paper, how many people will do it?

Questioning whether our journal is shamelessly gaining popularity? Does our journal need to take such a risk? Even if it is to be published, it can be published in another two years until Qin Ke goes to college! What is he, a high school student, doing in a hurry to publish a paper?

?Isn’t it just for fame? Why should we take such a big risk just to gain his reputation?”

The editor-in-chief who had been silent for a long time finally spoke: "Professor Zhang is right. Qin Ke is still a high school student. Whether or not he publishes his paper will not affect his eligibility for recommendation. If our journal really wants to publish his paper, we can wait."

He has graduated from high school, or at least he has signed a recommendation contract with the university, so he can be considered a quasi-college student, and it is not too late to publish."

Xiao Mao said resolutely: "Chief Editor, Professor Zhang, I just hold the opposite view. It is precisely because Qin Ke is the most famous now and is still a high school student that we have to publish his paper so that others can see that we are breaking the rules.

Courage and courage, we want to tell everyone that the only basis for judgment in our journal is the quality of the paper and the level of the author, rather than the identity and reputation! I think this paper should be published in the next issue of the journal, and I would like to sign and recommend it.

I will bear all the slander with my body!"

Signature recommendation is also one of the rules of this magazine. Only the editor-in-chief has the right to do so. There is only one opportunity a year. When the expert group does not agree to publish a certain paper, he can resolutely demand publication and sign his name as

guarantee.

Once there are any loopholes in the paper, or it is proven that the author has committed fraud, the recommending editor will be greatly criticized, and may even have to take the blame and resign, and his reputation will be greatly damaged.

Xiao Mao has never used this right, but today he decided to use it for Qin Ke.

This is going to burn the boat!

Editor Wei couldn't help but persuade: "Old Xiao, since we have worked together for so many years, I advise you to think twice about this matter..."

Xiao Mao said firmly: "Editor Wei, in recent years, the mathematics world has focused on seniority and seniority, and it has become lifeless. It is rare to find such a talented student. I am willing to bet this time to help him stand higher and let him stand taller."

Our journal can move into a new future!”

He said eloquently: "If this reform is not recognized by all sectors of society, or there is strong opposition, I am willing to take the blame and resign. But if this exception is recognized by all sectors of society, I hope that our journal can issue an announcement to change it."

Get rid of that centuries-old rule!"

Several relatively young experts in their forties or fifties exchanged glances and stood up together: "We are willing to sign and approve the publication of this paper in the name of experts!"

Countless eyes fell on the editor-in-chief, because the final decision was still in his hands.

The editor-in-chief thought for a while and finally sighed.
Chapter completed!