Chapter 329 You are speechless(1/2)
The word "Huan" is a special word "六" and a word that few people know about in antique cultural relics.
At least, two of the three experts on the expert table had no idea, because one was working on bronzes at the Palace Museum and the other was specializing in calligraphy and painting. However, folk collectors heard about it occasionally.
But after a little hesitation, the three experts raised their own questions out of their hearts.
Wang Hua, a retired expert from the Palace Museum, stumbled and asked first:
"I don't agree with Li Fan's view. The word "happy" determines that a screen was from the Qianlong period, and I don't agree with it. Wouldn't the counterfeiter realize this?"
Li Fan smiled and said to the audience: "I will do a test. The audience who came to the scene know more or less the industry, but their level is slightly different. I guess there must be many people who are good at research. I will give you some questions.
May I ask, does anyone know what the "后" is in "Zi Mozi's guarding for more than 1"? It's the "后" that "后"!"
As soon as this said, there was silence at the scene. Among the more than 150 spectators, only three or four raised their hands.
Li Fan nodded and asked again, "What about the 'crawling' of 'crawling' among the apes?"
Three people raised their hands, but Li Fan did not ask questions. He nodded and asked: "What about the 'shame' in the 'making of Jianzhongyuan'? What about the 'curdness' in the 'curdness'? The 'curdness' in the 'curdness' of the 'curdness' in the 'curdness' of the 'curdness' in the 'curdness' in the 'curdness' in the 'curdness' in the 'cur
After asking some questions in a row, 95% of people were in a state of confusion. After all, who would have studied the word "fake"? Even those who learned it in school have long forgotten them. Not to mention them, even if the three experts gathered together, the few words "fake" mentioned by Li Fan were not called complete.
The identification ability involves many fields such as literature, history, archaeology, materials science, art, customs, etc., but if you want to master all aspects of knowledge thoroughly, how can you have so much energy?
Li Fan said: "Everyone has seen that the 150 friends here who are interested in antiques and cultural relics really have only a handful of masters of Tongfa. Moreover, the usage of Tongfa word for Huan is very rare, and even in this line, it is rarely seen."
Wu Long shook his head: "Or won't it? Since it exists, how can you be sure that only you know about this? Does the counterfeiter do not understand the word "happy"?"
Your sister, let’s argue!
Li Fan just didn't know that two of these three didn't understand the extremely rare history of the word "日", otherwise, I would just ask them, do you know? They just stopped the food. The experts didn't know, but the counterfeiter knew that your experts were not good at their level!
Li Fan pursed his lips and wasted his words, "Okay, this word "happy". I told the audience carefully why I can judge with the word "single"!
I have said before that this "happiness" is a fake "happiness", which is basically difficult to see after the Han, Tang and Song dynasties. In literary works, I will introduce it to you:
During the Ming Dynasty of our country, the word "Huan" appeared 10 times in all literary works, only 10 times. They are:
In Zuo Guoji's "Farewell to Nantangzi", "I am so confused and amused, but I am not the most ancient talent."
In Yan Song's "Seeing Yong Xiu to give to Zhang Sheng, I sent him a poem "The song of lamentation is attracted by Feng Huanqi, and I feel that I am playing Gong Yu Guan."
...
Ruan Hanwen said in "Showing Brother" that "I am happy and arrogant, and I am proud of all the heroes."
In Chen Duo's "Send to Zhang Wenzhao with Rhyme", "A quiet official is willing to be a clumsy, and he smiles at Feng Huan when he meets people."
And in the Qing Dynasty, the word 'happy' no longer appears in literary works!
Guan Tong in the audience was completely stunned and confused. Who is Ruan Hanwen? Who is Zuo Guoji? Who is Chen Duo? I only know Li Bai, Du Fu, Su Shi and others, who are these people?
Also, why are you, Li Fan, so sure that the word "Huan" only appeared ten times in the history of Ming Dynasty literature? But I think you are not bragging, because you, you actually listed all the ten words "Huan" in one breath, and didn't even hit adzes. I have no reason to doubt you for such awesome behavior!
Is this Li Fan so powerful? Oh my God, I will search him online later!
Guan Tong, who had just returned to China, didn't understand the "national conditions". She was shocked and trembled, her eyes were full of admiration. The other audiences had been baptized by Li Fan for many times and now they had "antibodies". They would not be shocked. After all, this is Li Fan's routine operation, and everyone has experienced too much!
However, the audience who admired themselves were still very applauded.
Li Fan concluded: "Looking at the history of Chinese literature, as a word "Huan" appears 140 times in total. After the Ming Dynasty, the word "Huan" is no longer seen in literary history.
However, although the word "Huan" did not appear in the literary works of the Qing Dynasty, this "Huan" has slightly rekindled in various handicrafts, such as porcelain, carvings, etc. The word "Huan" I have seen in the Qing Dynasty antiques, all of which were in the Qianlong period and did not appear in other periods."
Wang Xiang asked: "Why did this word appear in the Qianlong period?"
Li Fan explained: "There are several explanations of this, but none of them can stand scrutiny, and there are not many scholars who have studied this word. After all, the word "fixed" is extremely easy to ignore in objects.
I believe that there are hundreds of words on the screen on the stage. The teachers shouldn’t have noticed some words in particular just now, right?”
Several teachers said nothing, Li Fan continued: "Let's talk about this word, because the 8 antiques are not particularly famous and are relatively scattered. There are four in China, and the rest are abroad. I don't think there are many scholars who carefully notice this detail!
This is an extremely unpopular common sense in the industry, so cold that many experts may not know about it! If the counterfeiter happens to know about it, then who are he going to cheat?
Lie novice? Be a beginner? If you plan to deceive the public, traditional Chinese characters are enough. If you make a fake character, you will probably have to explain it to everyone. The key is, after you explain, do people believe you?
Besides, even if this screen is a modern product, such as wood, handmade gems, you will have to buy this modern product at least two million.
Ordinary people can’t afford to consume, but you can’t cheat collectors. Rich people will look for people to see them, and there is no need to make fraud."
Wu Long said: "But, in this industry, some high-end fakes are just to cheat experts! You know the famous "Eight Paintings" incident, Li Fan?"
Respond to argue again!
It is necessary to use 10% of the possible conditions to question Li Fan's 90% correctness. This is an expert trying his best to maintain his authority in identification.
Li Fan's smile disappeared, his voice was a little cold: "There is a fundamental difference between the "Eight Paintings" incident and today. If you don't discuss it, I will reconcile it again.
If this screen is fake, the following conditions are required to trigger it at the same time:
1. The counterfeiter is a master-level figure.
2. The master happened to think of using this word to fake it.
3. The target customers of fraud are high-end collectors or scholars.
You can imagine the possibility of these three triggers at the same time."
Li Fan said this, looked at the three experts and continued: "
The most important point is that since the excellent wood, excellent gems and exquisite handicrafts have been exhausted, even the slightest detail of the word "无" is considered. The purpose is to define the screen as an antique from the Qianlong period.
No one has any questions about this, right?
However, all conditions are extremely exquisite, but why do you ignore the most conspicuous place? Why is this screen not old? Instead, it is so brand new?
If you plan to make it into a fake, people with a brain will make it artificially. This is the biggest loophole and it is completely unreasonable!"
The experts were speechless by the debate, and the audience nodded suddenly to agree:
"Yes, why didn't I think of this floor?"
"Li Fan makes sense. If he tried hard to make a fake, he would lose his superficial work. This deceased person would not do it!"
"Look, the expert was said to be out of power by Li Fan!"
...
Li Fandao: "Summary, from the analysis of the word "happy", the probability of this screen being fake basically does not exist! It was from the Qianlong period!"
Before, Li Fan just said slightly politely, "It may be during the Qianlong period." Now he has changed his words and said with certainty, so he is not polite.
Wang Hua said: "It may also be the handicrafts of today, they are made from antiques, not without this possibility."
Damn, it's so annoying, and he argues.
If you argue like this, give you a leverage and you can all lift the earth up.
Li Fan's face was in vain. Just as he was about to speak, Guan Tong said: "I think the angle we consider is completely wrong. Why do we find various angles to confirm that this screen is fake? Why don't we use facts to speak, and show examples to prove that this screen is real?"
Wang Xiang said: "Guan Tong said this well. We have gone astray. We are now trying to prove from all angles that this is a fake. If possible, we can come up with 180 possibilities of fraud. This is a manifestation of excessive suspicion. Let's change the angle and analyze it from the positive direction.
Li Fan, do you have any evidence that it is true, except for the word "happy".
Li Fan said: "Actually, the word "happy" is enough to combine the quality of the entire screen. Well, I'll say a few more words! First of all, what do the three teachers think this screen is a basis for modern products?"
The atmosphere on the stage was a bit strange. Although it was not tense, it was undercurrent. Everyone spoke in a calm voice, but a little cold.
Director Lu: "This thing is as mentioned before. It's good everywhere, it's new."
Li Fan asked: "What if there is any other basis besides this new one?"
The three experts said nothing again.
Li Fan said: "First of all, the Palace Museum contains a Taishi chair from the Kangxi period. It is brand new and newer than this screen. The formation of the skin is conditional, and oxidation is processed, and it is not a big problem to preserve it properly. If you are interested, you can go to the Palace Museum to take a look."
Li Fan glanced at the screen again and said, "This screen carved the famous Ten West Lake Scenes. Does anyone know which Ten West Lake Scenes are?"
After a viewer raised his hand to answer, Li Fan nodded and pointed to one of the screens, "Everyone knows that there are "Willow Was Hearing the Warbler" among the ten scenes, but why does the screen say "Willow Was Hearing the Warbler"?"
Everyone was stunned, yes, why didn’t anyone observe this?
Li Fan explained: "Does some people think this is a fake? The engraving master "missed the knife"? Let me tell you that in the first year of Qianlong, it was called "Liuan Wenying". This "Liu Lang Wenyingying" was modified by later generations. This is proof of "The Big Break Screen of the Colorful West Lake Ten Scenery", so you can go and have a look.
Moreover, the wind blows the willows and waves, so I can't hear the sound of the orioles very clearly. This is the evidence that I judged that it was before the Qianlong period 2.
Let’s look at it again. There is a detail in the “Thunder Peak Sunset” in the screen. When you look at the tower, you use a lot of hooking techniques. This technique has been lost.
…”
After talking for a while, Li Fan looked at the huge screen as high as 3 meters and said, "If this is treated as a fake, how much money will it cost!"
The treasure hiding person was overjoyed and quickly bowed to Li Fan: "Thank you, Teacher Li, thank you, Teacher Li!"
Everyone looked at the three experts again, and the three experts blushed.
The answer is already very clear. Li Fan wasted a lot of talk again by the word "stable" and then the dust settled.
At this moment, suddenly, Director Lu smiled and said, "Oh, look, let's take a look. It's really rare to have a character like Li Fan among the younger generation!
I'm so happy today, talent! It's rare to have talent!"
Wang Hua also clapped his hands, "The genius of Chinese studies is the genius of Chinese studies, I will give you a thumbs up!"
Wu Long even clasped his fists with both hands: "I admire you! I admire you!"
To be continued...