For example, it lists several failures of Cao Cao, such as trapped in Nanyang, dangerous in Wuchao, dangerous in Qilian, and dead in Liyang, nearly defeated Beishan, and almost died in Tongguan. Among them, except for the historical records of Nanyang, Wuchao and Tongguan, there is no definite basis for the other few times!

For example, in "The Later Memorial of the Army", it says that Liu Yao and Wang Lang each occupied the prefectures and counties, and they did not fight for many years. Sun Ce occupied Jiangdong, which was inconsistent with the situation recorded in historical records.

This is the second argument!”

"I'll explain this," Professor Wang touched his beard and said, "This can be explained as an absence or misreport of history books. In the historical community, there are countless misrecords and errors. This is a normal phenomenon. I believe you, Li Fan, are also very clear about it.

A historical event would have a different name at that time and in later generations. The names of enemies, me, and friends may also be different. For example, the "Jinwu War" is also called the "Jinqing War". Some historical events will be omitted by people who record history or deliberately protected and not mentioned.

The "forced by Li Yang" mentioned in "The Memorial of Later Out" is easy to refer to the battle between Cao Cao and Yuan Shao in Guandu, but the original text mentioned "risk in Wuchao", which is obviously a repeated list...

Li Fan, after a rational analysis, your second argument is actually shaking and unable to stand!"

There was laughter in the room, and Li Fan also cooperated with "haha" twice, but the pronunciation of "haha" was a bit close to "haha". Li Fan continued: "Since I can't stand, then I will continue to talk about my third argument!"

Still don't refute!

Several professors were a little confused. This is definitely not in line with Li Fan's usual style! Li Fan loves to argue and expresses his own opinions the most. Why is he so "well-behaved" today?

Li Fan continued: "There are many unrecorded characters in "The Memorial of Later Departure". The original text said: "However, Zhao Yun, Yang Qun, Ma Yu, Yan Zhi, Ding Li, Bai Shou, Liu He, Deng Tong and Qu Chang, and more than 70 generals were stationed." Among them, except for "Yan Zhi", there were all people who had no evidence.

It is suspected that the forgers are not familiar with the history of Shu Han and are making up for the chaos. This argument is three."

"I'll say a few words!" This time it was changed to Professor Sun's speech. He said, "There are more than tens of millions of historical figures in the history of the Three Kingdoms, and it is impossible for everyone to have records. For example, Wu Yi in the Shu Kingdom was Liu Bei's brother-in-law. Even the official general of the cavalry did not officially write a biography, let alone others. Yang Xi, a literati of Shu Kingdom, wrote the "Biography of Ji Han's Minister", and many important figures Chen Shou did not write a biography...

Yours is not worthy of evidence.”

Li Fan did not mind at all and continued to laugh and said, "Okay, let's continue. The time when Zhao Yun died was different in "The Three Kingdoms: Biography of Zhao Yun" and "The Memorial to the Later Master".

The first Northern Expedition was in January 228, and Zhao Yun and Deng Zhi were demoted in Jigu unfavorably around June of that year. Based on this information, it can be concluded that Zhao Yun died between July and November of that year. The Biography of Zhao Yun recorded that Zhao Yun died in the seventh year of Jianxing.

Yang Tuo said: "But in terms of time, it is not too far away. There are many differences in time in various historical books. Moreover, there are no historians in Shu Kingdom. Chen Shou's reference to the time when Zhao Yun died may be based on the obituary."

Li Fan still did not make any rebuttals. He smiled and said, "Okay, everyone listen to my fifth argument..."

...

"Please listen to my sixth argument..."

...

“My eighth argument is…”

...

"The above are all 10 textual research arguments!"

Li Fan breathed a long sigh, then looked at the professors with a smile.

Zhuge Yun said in confusion: "These 10 are all in your articles. After our consideration, there is actually nothing that is impeccable. Have you not responded to our previous remarks at all?"

Li Fan said loudly: "No, the fundamental method of studying science and research is to 'seek truth from facts' and 'not believing without evidence'. It emphasizes listing of evidence and less theoretical development. This is the foundation of the matter. Therefore, I only display evidence and never analyze it by myself."

The professors looked at each other, hey, this is what he said, who will analyze it by himself?

After a long time, there was no refutation, just for the last sentence: only show evidence, never analyze it yourself.

Well, the professors were speechless, and we even analyzed it on our own.

Yes, Li Fan presented evidence one by one. You may have made mistakes in history, and that may have been missed. This one is actually quite suspicious of "picking and finding faults" against the evidence.

But we can't say what the professor said is unreasonable. In fact, what they said is reasonable, otherwise the professor at Peking University would be useless to have a meal? The reason why Li Fan did not refute it was because the essential reason of textual research was that he had to speak with evidence and facts.

outdoor.

The students were puzzled. Li Fan had been in for half an hour, but why hadn't he come out yet? The normal defense time was only about 10 minutes. You've been too long, right?

Seeing that a senior sister walked out of the defense room, Yang Shuo asked quickly: "Senior sister, what's going on inside?"

The senior sister said, "You come and go, it's very lively."

"Who has the upper hand?"

The senior sister said objectively: "Equalize the beauty."

After seeing the senior sister leave the defense room, the students quietly approached the door of the defense room and looked inside curiously.

At this time, Cui Yongnian said: "Then this "The Memorial for Later" is like this, let's talk about the later one-"

"Let's go," Li Fan said quickly: "Director Cui, the ten arguments just now were listed with the attitude of studying in the study of textual studies. Next, I have other arguments. We can discuss them. We will no longer discuss them based on textual studies."

The wrinkles at the corners of Cui Yongnian's eyes were stacked together. He squinted his eyes and looked at Li Fan, thinking: Boy, he is still dead, what else can he discuss? You really can't hold it in and want to refute us, right? Then let you talk.

Seeing Dean Cui nodding, Li Fan quietly moved his tongue, and was so suffocated that he said:

"Now let's talk about the content and speak freely. Let me talk about it first. "The Former Reaching the Master" is tragic, "The Last Reaching the Master" is in disgrace; "The Last Reaching the Master" is full of words, and "The Last Reaching the Master" is difficult and simple; "The Last Reaching the Master" is embarrassing and complicated. It is really not like Zhuge Liang's own work."

"Otherwise, otherwise," Yang Tuo said, "The "Last Table" and "Previous Table" and other articles of Zhuge Liang have the following common characteristics:

It emphasizes parallelism and parallelism, with the characteristics of parallelism in Han fu; its syllables are sonorous, vertical and horizontal, horizontal, layered, and thorough reasoning; its emotions are sincere and its language is refreshing and easy. The difference is that the "Previous Table" focuses on narrative and lyricism, while the "Last Table" focuses on discussion and refutation, complement each other, and combines them into a perfect jade. Therefore, it should be done by one person."

Li Fan shook his head and said, "I don't agree with Professor Yang's point of view! I think--"

puff!

Cui Yongnian and others all showed knowing smiles. Finally, it was time for you, Li Fan, to be unable to hold it in. Once you have reached the academic discussion, you kid will never be as honest as you are today!

Li Fan said in confusion: "What's wrong?"
Chapter completed!