After a group of old people looked at the painting carefully, they stepped aside to discuss whose work it should be. {{}{}

Liu Yuanshan did not forget to greet Liu Suifeng and Zhou Nanming again, and snorted coldly, "I was so anxious just now. It's really your turn to appreciate it. Why didn't you come here? I can't tell you why later, hum!"

His words made Liu Suifeng and the others feel extremely stressed on their shoulders. At this autumn auction, they failed to collect particularly good items and even incorporated a lot of imitations. The old men were very angry. If they made mistakes in the appraisal this time, they would probably be scolded again.

With the same thought as going to the battlefield, Zhou Nanming and Liu Suifeng looked at each other and smiled bitterly. They really meant that they were good friends and had the same difficulties.

When Liu Suifeng approached the front of the painting, he also asked Liu Yuqing who was enjoying the drawing softly, "Little sister, grandpa and the others have revealed to you whose work is this?" Liu Yuqing replied, "No, if you want to know, wait and ask grandpa and the others."

Liu Suifeng said with a face, "Don't I dare? Sister, you have to pull me at this time. Grandpa and the others didn't say that, what about Zhou Xia!"

Liu Yuqing was so happy in her heart, but on the surface she looked very sorry. "Ah, sorry, I forgot to ask him. Otherwise, I will reluctantly go to him and ask him for help you?"

Liu Bifeng shook his head quickly and smiled. You should know that he would ask him for advice. He would pull down his face and that boy's tail would not be able to go up to the sky. Liu Yuqing was a family at least, and Liu Suifeng felt that it was nothing. Anyway, she didn't know his nature and background.

It still has to rely on your own six!

Liu Suifeng believed that with his own and Zhou Nanming's level, if he didn't believe it, he wouldn't be able to identify it.

Zhou Nan obviously had the same thoughts as him. If he really asked them to ask Zhou Xia for help, it would be more difficult than killing them.

The two of them quickly calmed down and made a serious assessment.

Both of them were born into a scholarly family. Since childhood, the elders have consciously cultivated their knowledge of calligraphy and painting. They have laid a solid foundation and have good attainments and understanding of artistic works. Liu Suifeng is good at calligraphy, while Zhou Nanming is more talented in painting. If it weren't for Zhou Xia's external control, their strength would be without any suspense or pressure to kill him in seconds.

But at present, Liu Suifeng and the others could only make an appraisal in a hard time, and they could naturally see that this paper and this ink were definitely an old thing. But the key to the problem is, whose work this Damn is, there is no information representing the author's identity at all. Isn't this purely a cheating person?

Zhou Xia was so lucky that he actually found such a difficult unfinished work for him.

No matter how much they complain, they still have to do a real appraisal.

Cuckoo, falling huā, waning moon.

Now, they can only trace the origin from this picture that is just a prototype, and even imagine what style the finished work will look like after such a first draft, and what the master painter's technique will be.

Soon, both of them came to an unanimous conclusion that the painting was most likely imitating the Bada Shanren Zhu Da.

Only Zhu Da's works have such strong Chinese feelings and such few huā birds. In Zhu Da's own words, they are "integrity".

Zhu Da's works are about depicting fewer objects; secondly, they use fewer pens when shaping objects. It can be said that when they truly reach the state of cherishing ink like gold and winning more with less, only Bada Shanren has truly achieved this point of being unprecedented and unparalleled.

Like this unfinished work, a cuckoo, a few fallen huā, and a waning moon, although there are few objects to describe, the thoughts and feelings you want to express, as well as the tone and outline of the whole painting, can be considered complete.

But the two of them were not sure that this was the work of Zhu Da, a Bada Shanren.

Zhou Nanming whispered to Liu Suifeng and said, "I think the style of this painting is somewhat similar to Zhu Da. But there are also many obvious flaws. It is very likely that it is a copy of Zhu Da's imitation of Zhu Da. First, Jin Mou is just the first draft, but I see that this brushwork and painting skills are still quite different from Zhu Da's. Also, I don't believe that Zhou Xia is so lucky. If this is really the original work of Zhu Da, he will have all the good feelings in the world."

Liu Suifeng nodded and agreed. Zhou Xia's sudden rise not only made Zhou Nanming feel extremely threatening, but also for Liu Suifeng, this is also a very bad phenomenon, because Zhou Xia is Liu Yuqing's loyal follower.

But Liu Suifeng is obviously much more serious than the literary young man Zhou Nanming. He immediately said to Zhou Nanming, "There are many possibilities among them, and later generations have the greatest possibility of copying. We can emphasize this point. However, we must first look at the old men's opinions and follow their wishes."

Zhou Nanming nodded and said, "The appraisal of calligraphy and painting is more subjective and has great variables. Even the old men may not be fully confident. As long as we can stand invincible."

The two good friends discussed in a low voice. Drawings like this are indeed not as straightforward as identifying famous paintings. They are genuine, and imitations are imitations. The key is to see what the elders think. In any case, they will be confused first before talking about this.

Soon, a group of old experts on the other side of Liu Yuanshan also came up with a general conclusion.

Of course, they wouldn't talk first, and Liu Suifeng and Zhou Nanming must go to the exam room first.

Of course, Liu Yuqing couldn't escape, but her expertise was not the case. Even if the identification was wrong, as long as it was not too outrageous, the elders would not be too many.

Liu Suifeng, who is specialized in calligraphy and painting appraisal projects, is different. They rely on this to make a living.

Liu Yuanshan did not disappoint, so he immediately recruited Liu Suifeng and said, "Suifeng, although there is not much time and there is no way to carefully examine it, but you might as well tell your own opinions. It doesn't matter if you say it wrong."

Liu Suifeng secretly complained, it would be strange if it doesn't matter. Thinking of this, he became more cautious, while carefully considering the words in his heart while observing the expressions of the old men. He is quite capable of observing words and expressions, hoping to get something useful from their expressions.

Time could not tolerate Liu Suifeng thinking more. He first was humble and immediately explained the conclusion he had discussed with Zhou Nanming before. First of all, he was sure that this was a genuine old painting, and then said that all possibilities exist.

Of course, he was more inclined to later generations to copy Tu Sha Da, but his writing skills were not good enough, but he could not get the spirit. He did not have the deep foundation of Zhu Da and the exquisite objects as a complete picture. In the end, he had to be sad and sad, not knowing how to finish them, so he had such an unfinished work.

After saying this, Liu Ruanfeng looked at Liu Yuanshan and the others with his expressions as if he was a primary school student who had finished his homework, waiting for the teacher to correct it.

Unfortunately, they did not express their opinions and called Zhou Nanming to misunderstand "Nanming, tell me what you think."

Zhou Nanming is worthy of being a good friend who wears a pair of pants with Liu Suifeng. He did not betray Liu Suifeng. Although his expression is somewhat different from that of Liu Suifeng, his meaning is the same.

They were not optimistic about Zhou Xia’s purchase of this work from a street stall, and believed that the greatest possibility was a copy of Zhu Da’s practice work by the Qing Dynasty, and it had no value at all.

You should know that after Zhu Da became famous, later generations praised him for imitating his works, but no one could reach the same level as him. It is not particularly strange to have such a copy, and this is also the most reasonable interpretation of the scriptures.

Zhou Nanming finally used the probability of the current light-moving experience to interpret the scriptures. "If this work is one percent genuine, the rate of oranges is one percent, then the probability of being copied by later generations is 99 percent. I believe even more that this painting belongs to the 99 percent probability."

Liu Yuanshan's expression remained unchanged and asked them, "Is this what you think?"

Liu Suifeng and Zhou Nanming both nodded and said it, but it was too late to change.

Liu Suifeng could not see their tendencies from their expressions, but in order to leave a way out for himself, he immediately replied, "This is just a preliminary conclusion we have drawn. If we need to identify the real situation, we still need to carefully verify or listen to your grandpa to analyze and analyze it in detail."

Liu Yuanshan just pretended that he hadn't heard what he said, and wanted to show off these scrupulous things in front of him. Liu Suifeng was still too tender.

He immediately turned his gaze to Liu Yuqing and asked her, "Yuqing, what do you think? Do you think the same as Suifeng and the others?"

Liu Yuqing had just had a brief eye contact with Zhou Xia watching the show. Zhou Xia was quite confident in his own things. This can be seen from the smile and confident eyes on his face that Liu Yuqing chose to believe him.

When Liu Yuanshan asked, Liu Yuqing immediately replied, "Although I am not very different from the appraisal of calligraphy and painting, and the reasons they said are very reasonable, my opinions from them are still a little different. I think this painting is indeed the original work of Zhu Da."

"Tell me your reasons, it's not good to make random guesses. No matter whether it's an appraisal or anything else, you have to pay attention to tangible evidence and you can't act emotionally." Liu Yuanshan said to her with a smile.

His words made Liu Suifeng, who was alert, realized something was wrong.

Because he had experienced such a scene in the past, the old men often tried to change their minds, and if they really wanted to change, it would be a real mistake and they would often criticize them.

At the same time, Liu Suifeng also hopes that Liu Yuqing can change her position. Even if she is wrong, it will be everyone’s mistake. At most, she will be tied. If she wants to be innovative and unique now, it will not have much impact if she is wrong. If she is right, she can add points. This is not a fair battle.

Unfortunately, Liu Yuqing had made up her mind and was destined to sing the opposite tune with Liu Suifeng and the others.

Of course, everyone mentioned and felt the reasons she said.

But in addition to what Nan Ming and Liu Suifeng mentioned, this may be the reason for Zhu Da's work. Liu Yuqing also mentioned a few points, which she believed was the original work rather than the place where later generations wrote.

Liu Yuqing's voice was crisp and loud, and her aura was quite strong. "Although this copy was only the first draft, we can still see from the heavy pen tip that penetrated deep into the paper. The painter was already depressed and angry at the time, and there was no feeling of using the pen or meticulously crafted. This feeling of sorrow and pity that was full of later generations could not be copied when copying it. Unless he was also in that and huge depression and grief, he could reach such a situation. This is the first reason why I think it is the original work of Zhu Da, a Bada Shanren."

"Secondly, Zhu Da experienced ups and downs throughout his life. After his family and country were broken, his style of works also went from the earliest fine works to the strange and depressing style of his personal style. I think this can be reflected most intuitively from this painting. The waning moon of the birds have some traces of childishness, but it easily depicts his sad, angry, helpless and even confused mentality. I believe that when painting, he must be at the most important moment of change in his life, so he leaked out his feelings in his heart."

"There is also the work that was not completed in the end. I think this is one of the reasons why Zhu Da's original works. When God is about to give a great responsibility to this person, he must first suffer his mind and mind, exhaust his muscles and bones, and starve his body. He is empty and messed up his actions. This is most suitable for Zhu Da. When he was young, he lived a life of luxury and food without worries. His path to becoming a master of the painting world is full of ups and downs. Everyone knows the experiences, so I won't say much. My Lord

What I want to say is that the improvement of his painting level is not achieved overnight. But the style is fixed from this time, the kind of full on the pen tip and paper that we can all feel now. The sad and desolate gun that comes from the sunny lungs. It is precisely because his level at that time that he was not high enough that he could not follow up on this painting. He continued to pursue improvement on the road ahead, and finally left us with such an unfinished work of beads."

After Liu Yuqing said this, she felt a little moved and believed that it was true.

Zhao Xiangbo and Zhou Xia, one was afraid that the world would not be in chaos, and the other was sincerely supporting Liu Yuqing. They both applauded each other.

Zhao Xiangbo also smiled and said, "Little girl from the Liu family, this reason is well explained, which is exactly the same as my idea."

Liu Suifeng and Zhou Nanming's faces turned green. They all thought that Zhou Xia was not so lucky and were determined to demote this to death. Liu Yuqing immediately jumped out and slapped their faces hard.

Liu Yuanshan didn't know what to say about Zhao Xiangbo. He was gilding on his face or was he deliberately trying to praise Liu Yuqing.

No matter what Zhao Xiangbo’s real intention was, Liu Yuanshan could only choose to ignore it, but commented professionally, "Yu Qing’s words are very contagious and reasonable. But when we do the appraisal, we have to understand the painter’s thoughts and feelings when painting and what he wants to express, we also need to look at the most practical and objective evidence. For example, this paper and this ink are in line with the characteristics of this year."

Liu Yuqing smiled and said, "Grandpa, you must have come to the most accurate conclusion, right!"

Jia Yuanshan smiled and said, "Even old men, we dare not say the conclusions we have drawn must be accurate. But for such a work, there is only one conclusion, which is undoubtedly true. Xiao Zhou, this painting belongs to you. If you have any opinions, you might as well say them and communicate with each other.

Zhou Xia immediately expressed his clear statement, "I agree with Manager Jia's appraisal opinion and hope from the bottom of my heart that this is the original work of Zhu Da. His wish is quite beautiful, but if it is not the authentic product of Zhu Da, please point it out and give us the younger generations the opportunity to learn and make progress."

Liu Yuanshan laughed and said, "Xiao Zhou, you are joining our army! Two brothers Zhou, look, there are many talents in your Zhou family again! You are experts in calligraphy and painting. Please tell me, I won't be ugly. By the way, I almost forgot to be one for you. Zhou Tong and the two brothers are my best friends."

Zhou Xia hurriedly stepped forward to say hello, and he naturally had to make a good gesture in front of the elders of the same surname.

It seems that Zhou Shujun, who is about 80 years old, smiled kindly and said to him, "It is very rare that Zhou Xia can achieve the current achievements at such a young age. Your eyesight is indeed quite good. This drawing is a good treasure. I have also carefully read the secret porcelain water purification cup that Lao Zhao saw yesterday. It is quite precious. I hope you will be cautious in the future, continue to work hard, and give us the Zhou family more face."

Zhou Xia thanked him repeatedly for his praise, saying that he would be down-to-earth and take every step well in the future.

After Zhou Shutong encouraged Zhou Xia, he commented on his painting. "How old are we brothers? We have been fortunate to have seen some early works by Zhu Da in Japan. In Japan, Bada Shanren and his works are the most respected. He has a noble life experience, a disconnected situation, integrity, calligraphy and painting, and his academic knowledge. He is all alone. He has become the most accepted spiritual idol of the scholar-official class. Once his works appear, they will cause everyone to compete for "Cun Qian Zi Su

, People compete for treasure "Due to the demand of the Japanese market, the trend of imitation of Bada Shanren also appeared in the 1920s and 1930s, and Zhang Daqian had many copy works. We have a lot of experience in studying these copy works. Even if Zhang Daqian is called to be fake and real, at most he can only imitate his shape. Zhang Daqian, who has extremely personal and rich colors in his works, cannot imitate Zhang Daqian, who has no experience and spiritual realm, cannot imitate it."

"But this unfinished picture of the cuckoo's blood crying is filled with the profound and profound thoughts and feelings, and the feeling that gives us is exactly the same as the original works of Bada Shanren conveys to our feelings. Even as Yu Qing said just now, it comes even stronger. People who have not experienced the destruction of the country and the destruction of the family cannot make such an infectious painting. Even if it is just such an unfinished painting, Zhang Daqian cannot copy it, let alone other imitators."

"There are not many authentic products on the market now. Not only are collectors from all over the world competing for it, but even museums at home and abroad are looking for a lot of money. Therefore, you should not be discouraged by the Nanming Suifeng. Read more and learn more and experience more. This is what you should do now. Without any connection, our experience has been accumulated slowly in the process of appreciation."

Liu Suifeng and Zhou Nanming were encouraged, but this undoubtedly meant that their swollen faces were hit by another blow.

The fastest update, please bookmark humilou).
Chapter completed!